Punch through the Clutter
In the waning days of the age of print, when periodicals still ruled the marketing world, you had to punch through the clutter to make an impact.
Role: Copywriter
Industry: Government
Objective: Today we would call it a DEI initiative, but back then we simply called it diversity hiring.
Challenge: The National Security Agency needed diverse perspectives to gain an advantage in foreign intelligence and cyber security so they asked us to develop a campaign targeting hiring more ethnic minorities.
A primary channel used at the time was print periodicals. Unfortunately, all diversity hiring ads tended to blend together. Page after page after page, they all predictably featured a headshot of a minority model with a message of inclusivity. I wanted to punch through the clutter.
Approach: This idea came to me as I was looking at a typical Equal Opportunity Employer statement. You know, “We do not discriminate on the basis of …”. And it dawned on me … hiring in all its forms is a naturally discriminatory act. So, what do employers discriminate on the basis of? And in a flash, for the NSA, whose big thing is how smart they are, I had “we discriminate on the basis of intelligence.” After workshopping it a little, the team arrived at the language on the image.
Results: Even though the NSA loved it, they deemed it too risky. But what we came to discover was that it elevated their opinion of us quite a bit. They had been questioning our ability to break free of convention and this ad showed them that we could get a little edgy if they needed us to.